top of page
  • Space Ponder Writers

Webb is Challenging Our Understanding of the Cosmos

Updated: Jan 27

The mighty space telescope is still in its early stages of operation, but it has already made a number of significant discoveries that are challenging our view on the cosmos. These discoveries are leading to new insights into the origins and evolution of the universe.


Science is not static; it's a continuous process of discovery and refinement. As scientists gather new data, conduct experiments, and make observations, they often uncover unexpected findings that challenge existing models. This dynamic nature of science is what propels us forward, leading to breakthroughs and a deeper understanding of the natural world.



Here are some specific examples of how Webb is challenging our view on the cosmos:

  • Early galaxies: Observed galaxies that are more massive and mature than we thought possible at such an early stage in the universe. This suggests that the universe may have evolved more quickly than we thought.


  • Exoplanets: Evidence of water vapor in the atmospheres of exoplanets.



  • The early universe: Provided astronomers with a more detailed view of the early universe than ever before. This has allowed astronomers to study the formation of stars and galaxies in their early stages.




  • Dark matter and dark energy: Webb has observed more evidence of dark matter and dark energy. These mysterious substances are thought to make up most of the matter and energy in the universe, but we still don't know much about them.




Webb's discovery of water vapour in the atmospheres of exoplanets is also a major breakthrough. Water is essential for life as we know it, so the discovery of water vapour on exoplanets suggests that these planets could potentially be habitable. This raises the possibility that life may exist beyond Earth, which is a profound and exciting realization.


These discoveries are still in their early stages, but they are already challenging our view on the cosmos in a number of ways. The coming years are sure to bring even more amazing discoveries from Webb.


Webb Instruments Fae Scotland!


The Mid-Infrared Instrument captures and analyses the mid-to-long-infrared wavelength range, spanning from 5 to 27 μm. It comprises both a mid-infrared camera and an imaging spectrometer. MIRI is the result of a collaborative effort between NASA and the United Kingdom, with leadership from Gillian Wright at the UK Astronomy Technology Centre in Edinburgh, Scotland.



To maintain optimal functionality, MIRI must operate at an extremely low temperature, not exceeding 6 K (equivalent to -267 °C or -449 °F). This cooling is achieved through the utilization of a helium gas mechanical cooler strategically placed on the warm side of the environmental shield.





Scotland gets a chance to help us learn more about the cosmos. MIRI is a great example of collaboration between nations to further science and exploration. Thanks to the UK and NASA, we now have this incredible tool in our arsenal allowing us to explore the universe like never before. Yaldi!


Other models of the universe

The Big Bang theory is the most widely accepted model for the origin and evolution of the universe.


However, there are other models that have been proposed, such as the ekpyrotic model and the steady state model.


The ekpyrotic model proposes that the universe began in a collision between two branes, or membranes, in a higher-dimensional space. This collision created a hot, dense plasma that eventually expanded and cooled to form the universe we see today.


The steady state model proposes that the universe has always existed and is not expanding. Instead, new matter is constantly being created to fill the space that is vacated by galaxies as they move away from each other.


Both the ekpyrotic model and the steady state model have their own strengths and weaknesses. The ekpyrotic model is able to explain some of the observed features of the universe, such as the cosmic microwave background radiation, that are difficult to explain with the Big Bang theory.


The steady state model is simple and elegant, but it is difficult to reconcile with some of the observed evidence, such as the redshift of galaxies. The redshift of galaxies is a phenomenon in which the light from distant galaxies is shifted towards the red end of the spectrum. This is because the galaxies are moving away from us at high speeds. The steady state model cannot explain the redshift of galaxies, since it proposes that the universe is not expanding.


Despite their challenges, the ekpyrotic model and the steady state model continue to be of interest to cosmologists. These models provide alternative perspectives on the origin and evolution of the universe, and they help us to better understand the range of possibilities.


Another model of the universe that is gaining traction among cosmologists is the cyclic universe, which posits that the universe goes through cyclical patterns of expansion and contraction. This model suggests that the universe is not static, but rather dynamic and ever-changing. This model has implications for the end of the universe, as it suggests that the universe will not end in a Big Crunch, but rather in a Big Bounce, where the universe contracts and then re-expands.





The holographic universe model is an intriguing concept that suggests that the universe can be encoded in two-dimensional form. This model has implications for understanding the nature of reality, as it suggests that the universe is composed of information, rather than matter and energy. These various models of the universe provide an interesting perspective on the origin and evolution of the universe, and they continue to fascinate and challenge scientists.




The multiverse model, which suggests that there are multiple universes.


This model has implications for understanding the origin and evolution of the universe, and it also provides an explanation for why some physical constants and laws appear to be fine-tuned for life to exist. Another model is the string theory, which posits that the universe is composed of tiny vibrating strings that are the fundamental building blocks of matter. This model has implications for understanding the nature of reality, as it suggests that there is a deeper level of structure underlying the universe.




Some possible benefits of the multiverse model are:

  • It can explain some of the fine-tuning problems of the universe, such as why the cosmological constant is so small and why the physical constants are so precisely tuned for life.

  • It can provide a natural framework for the anthropic principle, which states that we observe the universe to be compatible with our existence because we can only exist in a universe that allows us to exist.



Some possible challenges of the multiverse model are:

  • It is difficult to test empirically, since we have no direct access to other universes. We may only infer their existence from indirect evidence, such as statistical anomalies or quantum entanglement.

  • It raises philosophical and ethical questions, such as what is the meaning and purpose of our existence in a multiverse? How do we assign value and responsibility to our actions in a multiverse?

  • It may violate the principle of Occam’s razor, which states that the simplest explanation is usually the best. The multiverse model introduces a lot of complexity and assumptions that may not be necessary to explain the observed phenomena.

  • While it can be argued it is fringe, depending on the multiverse chosen, if it is rooted in, for example, fractal geometry, there is a good chance that a strong multiverse is possible.


One of my personal favourite models is Eternal Inflation

A theoretical proposal in physics, eternal inflation refers to the expansion of the universe. It proposes that the universe is always expanding at an increasing rate because it is constantly inflating. Physicist Alan Guth proposed this idea in the early 1980s as a modification of the inflationary theory. Prior to that, my personal favourite was Sir Roger Penrose's CCC theory due some evidence of hawking radiation in the CMB.


Nowadays, I think Eternal Inflation theory is another contender. Maybe there would be a way to include the two together. They're similar but do differ. I've written more on Roger's theory over here.


Inflation is a phenomenon that occurred in the very early stages of the universe, shortly after the Big Bang. It is believed to have been a period of rapid expansion, during which the universe grew exponentially in size. This rapid expansion is thought to have smoothed out the irregularities and inconsistencies in the initial conditions of the universe, resulting in the uniformity and isotropy that we observe today.




According to the inflationary theory, this initial period of inflation came to an end after a fraction of a second, and the universe then entered a phase of gradual expansion. However, the concept of eternal inflation suggests that inflation did not cease entirely in some regions of space-time. Instead, it continued indefinitely in certain areas, leading to the formation of multiple "bubble universes" within a larger multiverse.


In eternal inflation, these universes act as separate entities, but like branches on a tree, each with its own set of physical properties and laws. They are thought to arise from quantum fluctuations during the inflationary phase, which cause the universe to split into different regions with different characteristics. As a result, each bubble universe may have its own distinct laws of physics and may evolve independently from the others.


It suggests that our universe is just one of countless bubble universes within a vast multiverse, each with its own unique properties. This idea challenges the notion of a single, unique universe and opens up the possibility of a broader cosmic landscape.


It has gained a bit of significant attention in the field of cosmology. It offers a potential explanation for the fine-tuning of the fundamental constants of physics and provides a framework for understanding the origins and evolution of the universe on a grand scale.


Eternal inflation is a fascinating theoretical concept that suggests the existence of multiple bubble universes within a larger multiverse. While it is still a subject of ongoing research and debate, it offers a compelling perspective on the nature of our universe and its place within the cosmos.


Due to the elastic nature of space-time, bubble universes may be a very realistic natural occurrence, as quantum fluctuations in the early universe could have caused the universe to split into different regions with distinct characteristics.



 

After learning about the impressive contributions of the Webb telescope, as well as the various discoveries and challenges to current theories, it becomes evident that advancements in scientific discovery are ceaseless. It's truly astonishing to contemplate what we've been able to uncover in such a short span of time.



What exactly is Webb's four main goals:

  1. To understand the first luminous glows after the Big Bang: to look back in time to the first galaxies that formed after the Big Bang. This will help us to understand how galaxies formed and evolved over time.

  2. To study the formation and evolution of galaxies: will study galaxies of all types, from small dwarf galaxies to large spiral galaxies. This will help us to understand how galaxies form and evolve over time, and how they are affected by their environment.

  3. To study the life cycle of stars: study stars from their formation to their death. This will help us to understand how stars form and evolve, and how they affect their environment.

  4. To study planetary systems and the origins of life: exoplanets and their atmospheres. This will help us to understand how planetary systems form and evolve, and whether there is life on exoplanets.


  • Dark matter and dark energy: Dark matter and dark energy are two of the biggest mysteries in cosmology.

  • The early universe: Webb is expected to provide new insights into the very early universe, including the first moments after the Big Bang. This will help us to understand how the universe formed and evolved in its early stages.

  • The search for life beyond Earth: Webb will be able to study the atmospheres of exoplanets in more detail than ever before. This may help us to identify exoplanets that are potentially habitable, and even exoplanets that may harbour life.


Here are some specific examples of predictions that JWST has confirmed:


  • The presence of heavy elements in the early universe: discovered galaxies that contain heavy elements such as oxygen and carbon just a few hundred million years after the Big Bang. This confirms predictions that the early universe was enriched with heavy elements from supernovae explosions.

  • The presence of dust in the early universe: dust in galaxies that formed just a few hundred million years after the Big Bang. This confirms predictions that dust was present in the early universe and played a role in the formation of galaxies.

  • The presence of organic molecules in the interstellar medium: organic molecules in the interstellar medium, which is the gas and dust between stars. This confirms predictions that organic molecules are common in the interstellar medium and may play a role in the origin of life.

  • The existence of supermassive black holes in the early universe: discovered supermassive black holes in galaxies that formed just a few hundred million years after the Big Bang. This confirms predictions that supermassive black holes formed early in the universe and played a major role in the formation and evolution of galaxies.


The mighty telescope is epic and its potential for discovery is vast. It is sure to revolutionize our understanding of the universe and our place in it. We can't wait to ponder the insights it brings. There will inevitably be some changes in the most widely accepted Big Bang model, but not so drastic, but rather subtle.



bottom of page